Data analysis reveals why planning applications fail in Croydon. Suburban character issues drive 38% of refusals. Learn the top 10 rejection reasons and expert strategies to get approved.
Overall Refusal Rate: 16% of householder applications refused (below London average of 18%)
Conservation Area Impact: 28% approval rate in conservation areas vs 76% elsewhere
Top Refusal Reason: Harm to suburban character (38% of all refusals)
Hotspot Areas: South Croydon, Sanderstead, and Shirley have highest refusal rates
Appeal Success: 41% of Croydon refusals overturned on appeal
Best Route: Prior approval success rate 91% vs 84% for full planning
London Borough of Croydon is one of London's largest boroughs by area, processing approximately 3,200 householder planning applications annually. Analysis of decision data from the Croydon Planning Portal reveals distinct patterns in what gets approved.
| Application Type | Applications/Year | Approval Rate | Refusal Rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| Single storey rear extension | ~1,350 | 88% | 12% |
| Two storey rear extension | ~520 | 74% | 26% |
| Loft conversion (dormer) | ~680 | 81% | 19% |
| Side extension | ~340 | 72% | 28% |
| Wrap-around extension | ~150 | 65% | 35% |
| Prior approval (larger home ext.) | ~160 | 91% | 9% |
Unlike inner London boroughs that focus heavily on heritage, Croydon planners prioritise "suburban character." This means maintaining gaps between buildings, consistent rooflines, and the leafy suburban feel that defines areas like Shirley, Sanderstead, and Selsdon.
Analysis of Croydon refusal notices reveals consistent patterns. Here are the 10 most common reasons applications are rejected:
Croydon's most cited refusal reason. Extensions that "fail to respect the established suburban character" by filling gaps between houses, creating terracing effects, or disrupting the rhythm of the streetscene.
Two-storey extensions frequently refused for causing "unacceptable loss of light, outlook, or privacy to neighbouring properties." Croydon strictly applies the 45-degree rule.
Extensions that are disproportionately large compared to the original dwelling. Common with wrap-around extensions and large dormers that dominate the roofscape.
Dormers that are too large, flat-roofed extensions visible from street, or roof alterations that harm the roofscape. Croydon has specific design guidance on dormer proportions.
Side extensions that close gaps between semi-detached houses, creating a "terracing effect" that harms suburban character. Very common refusal reason in Croydon.
Croydon has 14 conservation areas, including Addiscombe, South Norwood Lake, and Upper Norwood Triangle. Extensions that harm their character are refused.
Extensions that result in loss of off-street parking spaces. Croydon requires parking provision to be maintained, especially in areas with high parking stress.
Extensions that leave insufficient garden space or create cramped site conditions. Croydon expects properties to maintain usable outdoor amenity space.
Extensions that would harm protected trees or require removal of significant specimens. Croydon has extensive tree coverage with many TPOs.
Extensions using materials that don't match the existing building. While less common as a sole reason, it often contributes to "character harm" refusals.
Planning outcomes vary significantly across Croydon. Here's how different areas compare:
| Area | Designation | Approval Rate | Key Challenges |
|---|---|---|---|
| New Addington | None | 89% | Few restrictions, most flexible area |
| Thornton Heath | None | 86% | High density, neighbour impact focus |
| Norbury | None | 85% | Semi-detached character to maintain |
| Croydon Town Centre | Opportunity Area | 82% | Supportive of development, few houses |
| Selhurst | None | 81% | Victorian terraces, parking tight |
| Shirley | Suburban character area | 74% | Strict on gaps between houses |
| Sanderstead | Suburban character area | 71% | Large plots, but very protective |
| South Croydon | Partial conservation | 68% | Edwardian character, strict on dormers |
| Upper Norwood | Conservation area | 58% | Victorian villas, heritage scrutiny |
Before designing your extension, understand exactly what restrictions apply to your property. Conservation areas, TPOs, and suburban character designations all affect what you can build.
Check your property's planning constraintsCroydon sits in the South London pricing band - more affordable than central London but reflecting quality local builders. Here are typical costs:
| Extension Type | Typical Size | Cost Range |
|---|---|---|
| Single storey rear (3m) | 15-20m² | £50,000-75,000 |
| Single storey rear (6m) | 30-40m² | £65,000-95,000 |
| Side extension | 15-25m² | £55,000-85,000 |
| Two storey rear | 35-50m² | £110,000-150,000 |
| Loft conversion (dormer) | 25-35m² | £42,000-60,000 |
| Wrap-around | 40-55m² | £95,000-130,000 |
Croydon has a 41% appeal success rate - higher than the national average of 33%. This suggests planners may be overly cautious in some cases.
| Refusal Reason | Appeal Success Rate | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Suburban character | 48% | Inspectors often disagree with council |
| Terracing effect | 44% | Context-dependent - show precedents |
| Neighbour amenity | 35% | Technical evidence (BRE) helps |
| Conservation area | 28% | Harder to overturn heritage decisions |
Croydon Council offers pre-application advice from £250-400. Given the high refusal rate on character grounds, this is money well spent - particularly in suburban character areas like Shirley and Sanderstead.
Croydon pre-application advice serviceOur instant calculator shows realistic extension costs for Croydon properties. Know your budget before committing to expensive architect fees.
Get Free Extension EstimateCroydon has an 84% approval rate for householder planning applications overall - slightly better than the London average. However, this varies significantly by area, from 89% in New Addington to just 58% in Upper Norwood conservation area.
Standard householder applications take 8 weeks for a decision. Prior approval applications take 42 days. Croydon typically meets these targets for about 75% of applications.
Suburban character refers to the distinctive features of Croydon's residential areas: gaps between houses, consistent building lines, mature gardens, and matching architectural styles. Extensions that erode these features (like closing gaps between semis) are often refused.
Technically yes, but Croydon strongly discourages side extensions that close gaps between houses. Maintaining at least 1m to the boundary is recommended to avoid terracing effect refusals. Always check if your neighbour has already extended.
Yes - prior approval has a 91% success rate vs 84% for full planning in Croydon. If your extension qualifies (up to 6m for semi-detached, 8m for detached, single storey), this route is faster and more likely to succeed.
Croydon has a 41% appeal success rate - well above the national average. If your refusal was primarily on suburban character grounds and you believe the council was overly strict, an appeal may be worthwhile. Consider getting professional advice first.
Everything you need to know about building extensions without planning permission in London.
Data analysis of Greenwich refusals and expert tips for approval.
Complete guide to loft conversions including dormer design tips.
Complete breakdown of planning fees, architect costs, and professional fees.